The Morning: A failure of sanctions

Plus, Fani Willis, Iran and Open AI's video generator.

View in browser|nytimes.com Continue reading the main story February 16, 2024 Readers of this newsletter may remember when we cited experts who expected the economic sanctions on Russia to hobble its economy. That hasn't happened. Today, my colleague Ana Swanson explains why not. — David Leonhardt By Ana Swanson Trade Reporter Good morning. We're also covering Fani Willis, Iran and Open AI's video generator. A commercial port in Vladivostok, Russia, in August. Tatiana Meel/Reuters When sanctions fail After Russia invaded Ukraine in 2022, Western nations imposed the most extensive sanctions and trade restrictions in history on Moscow. Today, Russia appears to be doing OK. Its economy is growing steadily. Russia can't buy much from the West but has found new providers for drones, surveillance gear, computer chips and other gear. Its oil and gas sales are still strong, despite attempts to stop them. Russian officials say they have plenty of money to pay for their war. Moscow's continued strength is a humbling result for the U.S. and its allies. These nations make up more than half of the global economy, and they tried to weaponize their influence over trade and finance to weaken Russia. They hoped to make President Vladimir Putin a pariah and maybe even stop the war. Today, I'll explain why those efforts have fallen short — and whether they can be made to work again. Absorbing the blows The measures against Russia go far beyond traditional sanctions, which historically have targeted banks and elites. Those rules limit how much tech Russia can import, and they direct shipping companies and insurers to cap the price of Russia's oil at $60 per barrel — well below market rate. The sanctions took a toll. They raised the cost of many items for Russian civilians and forced the military to buy shoddier missiles and semiconductors. For Russian energy companies like Gazprom and Rosneft, exports to the West have plunged. But the Russian economy has proved surprisingly adaptable, thanks partly to its relationship with China. It may seem surprising that Russia could so quickly replace so much of its trade with the U.S., Japan and the E.U. But the rest of the global economy — especially China's — is large enough that the shift didn't take long. China already makes much of what Russia needs and can buy much of what it sells. Trade between China and Russia hit a record high last year as Russians turned to Chinese cars, electronics and weapons components. "China has to a large extent blunted the pain," said Eswar Prasad, a trade economist at Cornell University. Source: Silverado Policy Accelerator, Global Trade Tracker, UN Comtrade, ASEANstats, and national statistics offices | Data through the third quarter of 2023. | By Ashley Wu Another change has been the rise of a network of shipping companies, insurers and oil traders that does not answer to Western rules. This network, based in countries like China, India and the United Arab Emirates, has expanded since the war began to provide new channels for Russian oil. Thanks to this shadow fleet, Russia can get around the Western price cap on its oil by using shipping companies that don't comply with it. And Russians are still getting TVs, chips and cellphones through traders in Central Asia and the Middle East who buy them from the West and sell them at a markup. The West chose not to put in place some tough measures, such as a full oil embargo, for fear they could disrupt the global economy. Unlike some nations the U.S. has penalized before — think of Cuba, Iran and Venezuela — Russia is better integrated into world trade. It exports commodities other countries need, such as steel and fertilizer. And it still provides much of Europe's energy. Pain aimed at Russia would be felt well beyond its borders. The limits of Western power Finally, the newest sanctions — the ones that try to constrain Russia's access to technology and its oil sales — have not been as effective. The U.S. wields much less influence over these sectors than it does over the banking sector, which is tethered to the dollar. The new measures, imposed in 2022, made it harder and more expensive for Russia to do business abroad. But they haven't wounded its economy enough to make most Russians question the war. "The mood in Russia is, the whole world is against us, but we are managing quite well," said Maria Snegovaya, a senior fellow at the Center for Strategic and International Studies. U.S. officials acknowledge all this. Still, they say they imposed costs that other nations will have to weigh before violating international law. Officials call that a win, even if the measures didn't send Russia into a recession or end the war. Putin sees it differently. "The instruments and the policies of the United States are ineffective," Putin bragged during his interview last week with Tucker Carlson, according to a Russian government translator. He is surely not the only leader to notice the U.S. failure to cripple Russia. When China wants to menace Taiwan or India wants to assassinate perceived enemies on foreign soil, they will know that Washington couldn't turn Russia into a pariah when it broke the rules. In that way, sanctions in Russia have exposed the limits of U.S. power. For more Russia has found ways to flout global technology bans. Read how India profits from its neutrality in the Ukraine war. Aircraft parts made by Boeing, Airbus and others are flowing to Russian airlines, despite sanctions. Continue reading the main story ADVERTISEMENT THE LATEST NEWS Trump Trials Donald Trump Jefferson Siegel for The New York Times A judge set Donald Trump's Manhattan criminal trial over hush-money payments to the porn actress Stormy Daniels for March 25. That trial, the first of four faced by Trump, will test the limits of what benefits his campaign can yield from his legal troubles, Maggie Haberman and Jonathan Swan write. A New York judge could deliver a ruling in Trump's civil fraud trial today. Trump could be hit with hundreds of millions of dollars in penalties if found guilty. Trump is consolidating control of the Republican Party even as he faces 91 felony charges, Michael Bender writes. Georgia Fani Willis Pool photo by Alyssa Pointer At a hearing, Fani Willis, the district attorney leading the Georgia criminal case against Trump, rejected an accusation that she had lied about a romantic relationship with a fellow prosecutor. Willis testified for more than two hours, accusing the defense lawyers of spreading lies. The hearing, over whether Willis and her office should be disqualified from the case, will continue today. In interviews, Black women were conflicted about Willis's behavior and the treatment of her. Politics President Biden's lawyers objected to passages in the special counsel report questioning Biden's memory before its release, but the Justice Department rejected their complaints. A grand jury charged a former F.B.I. informant with lying about Biden and his son Hunter's business dealings — a setback for Republicans who had seized on the claims. The space-based antisatellite technology Russia is developing poses no immediate threat, a White House spokesman said. A House committee said it would subpoena Harvard for documents related to the university's handling of campus antisemitism. International A ship near Kharg Island, Iran. The New York Times Tankers insured by an American company transported billions of dollars of oil out of Iran in the past year, a Times investigation found The governing Conservative Party in Britain lost seats in two parliamentary elections, a blow to Prime Minister Rishi Sunak. The Greek Parliament legalized same-sex marriage and parental rights. The Orthodox Church had opposed the legislation. Senegal's highest court ruled that an election must be held as soon as possible after the president postponed a ballot scheduled for this month. New York Mourners at St. Patrick's, New York.  Sarah Blesener for The New York Times St. Patrick's Cathedral was once a flashpoint in conflicts between gay activists and the Catholic Church. This week it hosted the funeral of a transgender activist. F.B.I. agents searched the homes of two New York Fire Department chiefs as part of a corruption investigation. The New School wants to sell its Manhattan presidential residence for $20 million, becoming the latest small college offloading real estate to shore up budgets. Other Big Stories Woolly mammoths rendered by Sora.  via OpenAI OpenAI previewed Sora, an A.I. video generator. The technology could speed up the work of moviemakers — and the creation of online disinformation. The authorities in Kansas City said they were keeping two teenagers in custody after the Super Bowl celebration shooting. The city has one of the highest murder rates in the nation. A cancer surgeon at Columbia University pumped out studies he said could lead to better treatments. They were riddled with errors, investigators found. California will require ethnic studies classes in high school next year. There are already fights over how the discipline addresses the Israeli-Palestinian conflict. The U.S. repeatedly handed over migrant children to sponsors without thorough vetting and often failed to conduct timely safety checks, an independent watchdog said. Opinions For most of human history, work was divided into fast and slow seasons. If workers returned to that system, it would improve their output and their lives, Cal Newport writes. Since the pandemic, baking sourdough bread has become a way for people to both pass the time and gain control in their lives, Lexie Smith writes. Here are columns by Carlos Lozada on political memoirs and David Brooks on a healthy democracy. Discover more of the insight you value in The Morning. The Times is filled with information and inspiration every day. So gain unlimited access to everything we offer — and save with this introductory offer. MORNING READS Greenpoint, Brooklyn, during the filming of "Daredevil." Mimi d'Autremont for The New York Times And … action: After pauses for Covid and the Hollywood strikes, film sets have returned to the streets of New York. Art in space: Jeff Koons packed 125 miniature sculptures onto a Space X rocket headed for the moon. Falling out of flavor: Vanilla chocolate chip ice cream, once a best seller, is disappearing from stores. 36 hours in Phoenix: Eat dinner while enjoying a mountain view, and hike among the red rocks of Papago Park. Lives Lived: Joel Belz founded World, a pioneering magazine for a largely evangelical Christian readership. It sometimes cast a harsh light on religious figures whose behavior was less than holy. Belz died at 82. SPORTS Caitlin Clark Matthew Holst/Getty Images Record breaker: Iowa's Caitlin Clark officially became the leading scorer in N.C.A.A. women's college basketball history. Women's soccer: Lindsey Horan, the U.S. women's national team captain, apologized for saying most American fans of the sport "aren't smart" in an interview with The Athletic this month. Exit: The French soccer star Kylian Mbappé will leave Paris St.-Germain at the end of his contract this summer. Signs point to Real Madrid as the striker's next stop. M.L.B.: The league's commissioner, Rob Manfred, announced that he will step down in January 2029. Continue reading the main story ADVERTISEMENT ARTS AND IDEAS The god Jupiter as an eagle. The Trustees of the British Museum Stolen treasures: Last year, the British Museum announced that one of its curators had looted thousands of artifacts from its stores and sold them online. Six months later, more than 350 of the treasures have been recovered, and 10 of them will be displayed in a new exhibition, "Rediscovering Gems." More on culture The foundation that administers the National Book Awards announced that the prizes would be opened to non-American citizens who live in the U.S. "The only way to follow all of the action was to have multiple TVs": The late-night hosts discussed Trump's multiple criminal cases. THE MORNING RECOMMENDS … Matt Taylor-Gross for The New York Times Make a lasagna soup that delivers all the comfort of a classic with very little of the work. Apologize like you mean it. Splurge on upgrading your bedroom. Take a perfect nap on the couch. Take our news quiz. GAMES Here is today's Spelling Bee. Yesterday's pangram was continuum. And here are today's Mini Crossword, Wordle, Sudoku and Connections. Thanks for spending part of your morning with The Times. See you tomorrow. Sign up here to get this newsletter in your inbox. Reach our team at themorning@nytimes.com. Continue reading the main story Editor: David Leonhardt Deputy Editor: Adam B. Kushner News Editor: Tom Wright-Piersanti Associate Editor: Lauren Jackson News Staff: Desiree Ibekwe, Sean Kawasaki-Culligan, Brent Lewis, German Lopez, Ian Prasad Philbrick, Ashley Wu News Assistant: Lyna Bentahar Saturday Writer: Melissa Kirsch Need help? Review our newsletter help page or contact us for assistance. You received this email because you signed up for the Morning newsletter from The New York Times, or as part of your New York Times account. To stop receiving The Morning, unsubscribe. To opt out of other promotional emails from The Times, including those regarding The Athletic, manage your email settings. To opt out of updates and offers sent from The Athletic, submit a request. Subscribe to The TimesGet The New York Times app Connect with us on: Change Your EmailPrivacy PolicyContact UsCalifornia Notices The New York Times Company. 620 Eighth Avenue New York, NY 10018