The Morning: What’s stopping a deal in Gaza?

Plus, the 2024 campaigns, drug prices and Shen Yun.

View in browser|nytimes.com August 16, 2024 Good morning. We're covering the Gaza cease-fire talks — as well as the 2024 campaigns, drug prices and Shen Yun. At a demonstration in Tel Aviv.  Amir Levy/Getty Images Deal or no deal By Julian E. Barnes I cover international security issues. For weeks, the White House said the stars were aligned for a cease-fire agreement that would free the hostages held in Gaza. The framework of a deal first announced by President Biden has been in place since July. Since then, a phalanx of American officials has traveled frequently to the region, pushing Israel and Hamas to sign on. So far, they have failed. The last time I wrote this newsletter about the hostage talks, at the start of May, U.S. officials were describing Hamas as the holdout. (Israel had just made a major concession, dropping a demand to maintain checkpoints inside Gaza.) But by early last month, Hamas had shifted its position, made some concessions and signaled it was ready to move forward. Now, Washington sees Israel's prime minister, Benjamin Netanyahu, as the chief obstacle to a deal. In today's newsletter, I'll explain how the script flipped. The stars align It's an ideal time for Hamas to strike a bargain. The group is not destroyed and retains some military strength. But it is broken and severely weakened. Thousands of fighters are dead. Top commanders have been killed. Its leader, Yahya Sinwar, is isolated from other Hamas leaders. By some accounts, Gazan frustration with Hamas is growing. The group has even agreed to give up civilian control of Gaza, a sign it is ready to make concessions. In northern Gaza.  Omar Al-Qattaa/Agence France-Presse — Getty Images Hamas officials, angered by Israel's recent assassination of a political leader and negotiator, have said they won't participate in the latest talks, which began yesterday. But American officials think that position will change, and Hamas appears willing to meet with Qatari and Egyptian mediators. Additionally, there appears to be little more that Israel can accomplish militarily. Hardly any part of Gaza is untouched by Israeli bombs. Military operations are now games of Whac-a-Mole against Hamas fighters who disappear easily into the population. American officials say Israel reaps diminishing returns: The remaining Hamas fighters are harder to hit, but Palestinian civilians — devastated by the war — bear ever-heavier burdens. The local health ministry says 40,005 Gazans, both civilians and combatants, have already been killed. Israeli defense officials concede that Netanyahu cannot realize his goal of wiping out Hamas. They believe diplomacy is the only way to bring home the roughly 115 living and dead hostages still held in Gaza. While daring military operations have rescued seven hostages, negotiations have freed more than 100. Those who remain alive in Gaza appear to be beyond the reach of Israeli commandos, many likely hidden deep in tunnels and used as human shields to protect Hamas leaders. The holdup But Netanyahu seems unready for a permanent cease-fire. American officials had hoped he would conclude an agreement after his speech to Congress last month. Instead, my colleagues have chronicled how Netanyahu imposed new cease-fire conditions: He wants Israel to keep control of Gaza's southern border and has partially revived demands to screen Palestinians for weapons before they can return to their homes in the north — points negotiators thought Israel had already conceded. By The New York Times One reason may be political. Centrists have left the government, and a cease-fire agreement could break his right-wing coalition. When Netanyahu's defense minister — a hawkish member of his own party — said "total victory" was unrealistic, the prime minister flayed him for adopting an "anti-Israel narrative." Even if Netanyahu's coalition held, an end to the war would intensify calls for a new election. After the Oct. 7 attack exposed security failures, it's hard to imagine that Israeli voters will return Netanyahu to power. Delay might also allow Israeli forces to kill Sinwar, the mastermind of the Oct. 7 terror attack, delivering a major victory for Netanyahu and potentially a dose of redemption. If the negotiations drag on long enough, it's even possible Donald Trump will return to the White House and change the U.S. stance to align more closely with Netanyahu. The costs of delay This strategy is risky. Already, at least 40 hostages have died in captivity. There are doubts about how much longer those still alive can survive. And making a deal quickly holds the possibility — however slim — that Iran and Hezbollah might refrain from retaliating for Israel's recent assassinations. Of course, it is Hamas that started this war by attacking Israel on Oct. 7, killing about 1,200 people and taking hostages back to Gaza. And at important moments when a deal was at hand, the group rejected it. It is possible that once Netanyahu is ready for an agreement, Hamas will, once more, back away. But American officials believe the group is ready to cede a measure of power in return for a cease-fire and, crucially, a path to a Palestinian state. If Netanyahu is not ready for closure, Israel will miss the opportunity to halt the fighting, and some hostages may never return home. The tragedy of the war will only grow. More on the Middle East "I will support Israel's right to win its war on terror," Trump said at his New Jersey golf club. Earlier, he said he'd told Netanyahu to end the war quickly because "the killing has to stop." Trump falsely accused Kamala Harris of supporting an arms embargo on Israel, saying "Israel will be gone" if she wins. He said Chuck Schumer — the Senate Democratic leader, who is Jewish — was "like a Palestinian." Israeli settlers attacked a village in the West Bank, setting fire to vehicles and hurling Molotov cocktails, the Israeli military said. The Palestinian Authority said one person was shot dead. The Lebanese militia Hezbollah is yet to retaliate against Israel for the assassination of one of its commanders. It is assessing the risk of a backlash at home. THE LATEST NEWS Republican Campaign At a press conference, Trump said he was "entitled to personal attacks" against Harris. "I don't have a lot of respect for her intelligence," he added. Trump's lawyers asked the judge in his Manhattan criminal trial to delay sentencing until after the election. Trump's latest financial disclosure shows he made $300,000 for endorsing a Bible and has about $100 million in liabilities from civil lawsuits he lost. Trump's campaign hired one of his 2016 campaign managers, Corey Lewandowski, who has been accused of sexual harassment, as an adviser. Vance and Tim Walz agreed to debate on Oct. 1 on CBS. Democratic Campaign Biden still believes he could have beaten Trump, but the prospect of a brutal fight inside the Democratic Party persuaded him to quit the race. Here's how he decided. "Mind your own damn business!" Harris and Walz are leaning into patriotic and limited-government rhetoric, accusing Republicans of seeking to restrict freedoms. Harris plans to blame corporate price gouging for high grocery costs. Here's what economists say. North Carolina Democrats say Harris could win there. Republicans have held the state in all but one presidential election since 1980. Drug Prices President Biden and Vice President Harris. Eric Lee/The New York Times Biden and Harris announced lower Medicare prices for 10 prescription drugs, the first result of negotiations with pharmaceutical companies under a law the administration passed. The drugs include treatments for blood clots, diabetes and arthritis. See the full list and the new prices. The event was Biden's first joint appearance with Harris since he ended his re-election bid. "She's gonna make one hell of a president," he said. War in Ukraine Ukrainian troops have taken full control of Sudzha, a town about six miles beyond the Russian border, Volodymyr Zelensky said. Ukraine's surprise incursion into Russia is likely to make it harder for the Kremlin to renew its offensive in Ukraine's east, U.S. officials believe. But its forces are already closing in on one strategic town there. More International News Medical students and doctors protesting in Kolkata, India.  Piyal Adhikary/EPA, via Shutterstock The death and apparent rape of a female trainee physician at a hospital in Kolkata has fueled protests across India. Sweden recorded a case of mpox, the first outside Africa during the current outbreak. Read what to know about the virus. Typhoon Ampil dumped heavy rain on the greater Tokyo area, flooding some streets and forcing evacuations. Thailand's Parliament chose a 37-year-old heir of a political dynasty as prime minister, days after a court ousted the previous one. Other Big Stories A Shen Yun advertisement. The New York Times Shen Yun, a dance show by the persecuted Chinese religious movement Falun Gong, has earned millions across five continents. But performers say the group has been abusive, often discouraging dancers and musicians from seeking medical care. Federal prosecutors have subpoenaed Mayor Eric Adams of New York and his 2021 campaign as part of a corruption investigation. Gov. Philip Murphy of New Jersey picked his former chief of staff to succeed Senator Bob Menendez, who is resigning after a jury convicted him of corruption. Opinions Doug Sosnik presents 14 maps to show how Harris upended the race and consolidated Democratic support. Hunter Biden is an unregistered foreign agent, and he needs to be charged as one, Casey Michel argues. Readers objected to the editorial board's decision to stop endorsing New York candidates. Here's a column by David Brooks on understanding emotions. Subscribe Today The Morning highlights a small portion of the journalism that The New York Times offers. To access all of it, become a subscriber with this introductory offer. MORNING READS Ash Adams for The New York Times Precious cargo: In Utqiagvik, Alaska — the northernmost city in the U.S. — everything arrives by plane. But flying there can be treacherous. Mystery of the mind: Many people in vegetative states may be capable of thought, a new study suggests. "All-American spread": How the British learned to stop worrying and love peanut butter. Lives Lived: Peter Marshall once claimed that "The Hollywood Squares" hired him as host because its producers wanted "a complete nonentity." He turned out to be the perfect straight man, asking serious questions and coaxing cheeky rejoinders from celebrities. Marshall died at 98. SPORTS N.F.L.: The Philadelphia Eagles beat the New England Patriots 14-13 in a preseason game. The Patriots' rookie quarterback, Drake Maye, improved in his second outing. Media: ESPN fired the former N.F.L. player Robert Griffin III, as well as the "Sunday N.F.L. Countdown" host Samantha Ponder, in a move said to have been made for financial reasons. ARTS AND IDEAS In Rio de Janeiro.  Maria Magdalena Arrellaga for The New York Times In Brazil, a debate is roiling over maid's rooms, the cramped quarters that housed domestic workers in Brazilian homes for generations. The rooms originated with slavery but remained popular even after abolition, when affluent families employed Black domestic workers who toiled round the clock for little or no money. Some Brazilians still use them for live-in workers, though many others are transforming the rooms into libraries, lounges and walk-in closets. More on culture Photo illustration by Celina Pereira Embrace your summer dad bod. These movies show how. The authorities charged five people with providing the ketamine that caused Matthew Perry's death, including his personal assistant and two doctors. The late night hosts discussed Trump's use of Tic Tacs to discuss prices: "If someone hands you a breath mint, they're not suggesting you talk about inflation." THE MORNING RECOMMENDS … David Malosh for The New York Times Top one-pan pesto beans with toasted nuts and Parmesan. Commute with a great laptop backpack. Take our news quiz. GAMES Here is today's Spelling Bee. Yesterday's pangram was publicly. And here are today's Mini Crossword, Wordle, Sudoku, Connections and Strands. Thanks for spending part of your morning with The Times. See you tomorrow. Sign up here to get this newsletter in your inbox. Reach our team at themorning@nytimes.com. Editor: David Leonhardt Deputy Editor: Adam B. Kushner News Editor: Tom Wright-Piersanti Associate Editor: Lauren Jackson News Staff: Desiree Ibekwe, Sean Kawasaki-Culligan, Brent Lewis, German Lopez, Ian Prasad Philbrick, Ashley Wu News Assistant: Lyna Bentahar Saturday Writer: Melissa Kirsch Need help? Review our newsletter help page or contact us for assistance. You received this email because you signed up for the Morning newsletter from The New York Times, or as part of your New York Times account. To stop receiving The Morning, unsubscribe. To opt out of other promotional emails from The Times, including those regarding The Athletic, manage your email settings. To opt out of updates and offers sent from The Athletic, submit a request. Subscribe to The TimesGet The New York Times app Connect with us on: Change Your EmailPrivacy PolicyContact UsCalifornia Notices The New York Times Company. 620 Eighth Avenue New York, NY 10018