The Morning: The decline of deaths in Gaza

Plus, Ron DeSantis, diversity programs and Princess Diana.

View in browser|nytimes.com Continue reading the main story January 22, 2024 By David Leonhardt Good morning. We're covering the recent decline in deaths in Gaza — as well as Ron DeSantis, diversity programs and Princess Diana. In central Gaza.  Avishag Shaar-Yashuv for The New York Times A new phase For more than a month now, the Biden administration and other allies of Israel have been urging its leaders to scale back the war in Gaza. A more targeted battle plan, these allies have said, could reduce civilian casualties while still weakening Hamas. Some Israeli officials have made the same argument. It's now clear that Israel's leaders have followed the advice, at least partially. The Israeli military announced a strategic shift two weeks ago. It has reduced the number of troops in northern Gaza. And the most tangible sign of the change is the decline in deaths among Gazan residents, as reported by the Hamas-controlled local government. The number of Gazans dying each day has fallen almost in half since early December and almost two-thirds since the peak in late October. The chart here is based on a New York Times compilation of U.N. reports that rely on information from Gazan officials: Source: Gazan officials | Data is through Jan. 17, 2024. | By The New York Times Over the past week, an average of 151 Gazans, including both Hamas fighters and civilians, have died each day. The breakdown in deaths between fighters and civilians remains unclear — and a matter of debate. Earlier in the war, Gazan officials suggested that more than 70 percent of victims were civilians, while an analysis by an Israeli sociologist put the figure at 61 percent. It seems plausible that the share remains similar today, but also plausible that a lower percentage of deaths are among civilians now that Israel's attacks have become more targeted and the daily toll has declined. Is it enough? Either way, there are at least three important caveats to mention. First, the death toll in Gaza remains high, and some of the victims continue to be civilians, including children. "We live and witness sadness every day," Sameer al-Kahlout told Al Jazeera last week, while standing on rubble that he said had been his sister's home in northern Gaza. She had been hosting another brother and his family when their home exploded. "The Israelis bombed their house without any warning and killed them all," al-Kahlout said. Critics of Israel's war strategy say that the recent shift has been too limited and that its military should do much more to reduce the death toll. As a point of comparison, fewer than 50 Gazans (including Hamas militants) were killed each day on average during a 50-day war in 2014. Some of the advocates for a further reduction in fighting are Israelis, including military officials, who believe that destroying Hamas — as Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has vowed to do — is unrealistic. A smarter approach, according to this view, is to wind down the war and save the lives of the more than 100 Israeli hostages whom Hamas still holds. (My colleagues Ronen Bergman and Patrick Kingsley explained these tensions in this recent story.) Or too much? The second caveat points in the opposite direction. Other Israelis, especially on the political right, believe that the scaling back of the war effort has left their country vulnerable. Last week, Hamas fired at least 25 rockets from northern Gaza toward an Israeli city during a single day. Afterward, Itamar Ben-Gvir, Israel's national security minister, described the decision to withdraw some soldiers as "a serious, grave error that will cost lives." As Aaron Boxerman and Adam Rasgon — Times reporters based in Jerusalem — wrote: The rocket barrage also underlined the competing pressures Israeli leaders faced: the widespread popular demand to crush Hamas, the calls from right-wing politicians to be more aggressive in that campaign, the pleas by families of the hostages taken by Hamas to make concessions to secure their return and the outrage across the globe over the carnage and destruction in Gaza. And what now? The third caveat is that the Israeli military faces a difficult decision about how to proceed in southern Gaza. Israel controls much less of the south than the north, and many Hamas fighters are hiding in the extensive tunnel network around Khan Younis, a southern city. Israel has vowed to capture or kill all Hamas leaders involved in the Oct. 7 massacre. By The New York Times Above these tunnels, southern Gaza is packed with civilians, including residents and refugees. More than a million people fled to the south after Israel told them to leave the north for their own safety. In addition to using the tunnels, Hamas fighters are hiding among these civilians. Israel will not easily be able to eliminate the fighters without killing innocent civilians. This dilemma, The Wall Street Journal recently explained: … could culminate in a cease-fire that spares civilians but also allows Hamas to survive and recover, a strategic defeat for Israel. It also risks ending in an even greater bloodbath than in the north. (These Times maps and satellite photos show more detail about the state of the war.) The bottom line: Even with the caveats, the changes in Israel's war strategy have been significant — and somewhat overlooked. Israel has responded to international pressure in ways that suggest its harshest critics are wrong to accuse it of wanting to maximize civilian deaths. Yet the war is not over. Israel continues to inflict enormous damage on Gaza, and Hamas continues to attack Israel and call for its destruction. The war's next phase will almost certainly include further tragedy. More on the war Netanyahu repeated his opposition to the creation of a Palestinian state, rebuffing pressure from President Biden. Cells, décor and diapers: A Times reporter, guided by the Israeli military, toured an underground compound in southern Gaza where officials said hostages were held. Israel's critics have used the academic term "settler colonialism" to explain the country's history. Here's what it means. More on the Middle East The U.S. military said two Navy SEALs have died. They disappeared at sea during an operation to intercept Iranian weapons headed to Houthi fighters. The number of attacks on American troops in the Middle East increases the risk of deaths, a red line that could lead to a wider war, The Times's Peter Baker writes. The war in Gaza is damaging Egypt, Lebanon and Jordan's already shaky economies. Continue reading the main story ADVERTISEMENT THE LATEST NEWS Ron DeSantis Ron DeSantis Nicole Craine for The New York Times Ron DeSantis ended his campaign for the Republican presidential nomination. He endorsed Donald Trump. (Trump said he would drop the "DeSanctimonious" nickname.) DeSantis was once regarded as Trump's top challenger. "That early strength meant only that he had more room to fall," The Times's Nate Cohn writes about DeSantis's campaign. DeSantis failed to catch on with Republican voters, even in Iowa, where he visited all 99 counties and spent heavily on ads. Nikki Haley celebrated the demise of the DeSantis campaign. "May the best woman win," she said of her race against Trump. More on Politics Vice President Kamala Harris started a series of countrywide abortion rights events for the 51st anniversary of Roe v. Wade. California and Oregon told students and workers that they can skip Covid isolation if they are asymptomatic, a departure from C.D.C. guidelines. The White House has named a new lectern in the briefing room after Alice Dunnigan and Ethel Payne, the first Black women to cover the White House. War in Ukraine A strike on Donetsk, a Ukrainian city occupied by Russia, killed at least 25 people, officials said. They blamed Ukraine for the strike. Ukraine could soon run out of money to keep the government running if U.S. and European aid doesn't arrive, The Wall Street Journal reports. Russian celebrities faced backlash for attending a hedonistic theme party. One went on an apology tour through the war zone. South Asia In Ayodhya, India. Atul Loke for The New York Times Narendra Modi, India's prime minister, inaugurated a Hindu temple on the former site of a mosque, a triumph for Hindu nationalists. Indonesia's presidential front-runner is related to a former dictator. His rise has set off alarms. Climate The U.S. is pushing African nations to grow more traditional crops like cassava that can better withstand climate change. A growing number of states are incorporating climate change education into school lesson plans. New York may be next. Other Big Stories At least 72 deaths in the U.S. are connected to the recent severe winter storms. During a nationwide backlash against D.E.I. initiatives, some business leaders are moving away from diversity programs that might attract attention. Opinions Iran is too preoccupied with domestic issues — including an economic crisis and uproar over morality laws — to want a wider war in the Middle East, Reuel Marc Gerecht and Ray Takeyh argue. The Supreme Court inadvertently created a way for state legislatures to steal a presidential election. The window to fix it is closing, Lawrence Lessig and Matthew Seligman write. Gail Collins and Bret Stephens discuss DeSantis's exit and Trump's potential running mate. Discover more of the insight you value in The Morning. The Times is filled with information and inspiration every day. So gain unlimited access to everything we offer — and save with this introductory offer. MORNING READS The chaplain Devin Moss. Desiree Rios for The New York Times "You are loved": An atheist chaplain spent a year ministering to a convicted killer on death row. Together, they wrestled with how to face death without God. Fashion advice: Can you wear a vintage concert T-shirt to the office? Metropolitan Diary: Prince Charming in a pedicab. Lives Lived: Berish Strauch was a plastic surgeon whose pioneering procedures and devices to reattach or replace vital body parts included the first inflatable prosthetic penis. He died at 90. SPORTS N.F.L. playoffs: The Kansas City Chiefs are headed back to the A.F.C. Championship — their sixth straight — after beating the Buffalo Bills, 27-24. They will face the Baltimore Ravens, who beat the Houston Texans on Saturday. More N.F.L.: The Detroit Lions' historic run continues: They beat the Tampa Bay Buccaneers, 31-23, to reach their first N.F.C. Championship in over three decades. They will play the San Francisco 49ers, who beat the Green Bay Packers on Saturday. College basketball: Tara VanDerveer, the head coach of Stanford, won her 1,203rd game — the most in college basketball history, surpassing Duke's Mike Krzyzewski. Continue reading the main story ADVERTISEMENT ARTS AND IDEAS Tyler Comrie Fictional reincarnation: Princess Diana is ever-present in our culture. In recent years, she has been the subject of movies, television shows and plays — including "Spencer" and "The Crown." The former princess of Wales, Times critic Jesse Green writes, is entertainment gold: "The perfect combo of stardom, tragedy and unanswerability." But less than 30 years after her death, Jesse argues that Diana deserves more time to rest in peace. "She is still too blazingly alive to be dragooned into trauma porn," Jesse writes, "mauled with the excuse of reincarnating her." More on culture Queen of Sundance? Kristen Stewart starred in two of the festival's most discussed films so far: "Love Me," opposite Steven Yeun, and "Love Lies Bleeding," with Katy O'Brian. This year's Oscar nominations are announced on Tuesday. This is what to expect. THE MORNING RECOMMENDS … Jim Wilson/The New York Times Try Marcella Hazan's five-star Bolognese sauce. Deepen your yoga practice with these books. Eliminate period stress with a menstrual cup. Take our news quiz. GAMES Here is today's Spelling Bee. Yesterday's pangram was nomadic. And here are today's Mini Crossword, Wordle, Sudoku and Connections. Thanks for spending part of your morning with The Times. See you tomorrow. — David Sign up here to get this newsletter in your inbox. Reach our team at themorning@nytimes.com. Continue reading the main story Editor: David Leonhardt Deputy Editor: Adam B. Kushner News Editor: Tom Wright-Piersanti News Staff: Desiree Ibekwe, Lauren Jackson, Sean Kawasaki-Culligan, Brent Lewis, German Lopez, Ian Prasad Philbrick, Ashley Wu News Assistant: Lyna Bentahar Saturday Writer: Melissa Kirsch Need help? Review our newsletter help page or contact us for assistance. You received this email because you signed up for the Morning newsletter from The New York Times, or as part of your New York Times account. To stop receiving The Morning, unsubscribe. To opt out of other promotional emails from The Times, including those regarding The Athletic, manage your email settings. To opt out of updates and offers sent from The Athletic, submit a request. Subscribe to The TimesGet The New York Times app Connect with us on: Change Your EmailPrivacy PolicyContact UsCalifornia Notices The New York Times Company. 620 Eighth Avenue New York, NY 10018