The Morning: Modi’s India

Plus, Israel, D-Day and Brooklyn

View in browser|nytimes.com June 6, 2024 Good morning. Today my colleague Alex Travelli helps you understand Modi's India. We're also covering Israel, D-Day and Brooklyn. —David Leonhardt Narendra Modi at his party's headquarters.  Atul Loke for The New York Times Modi's choices By Alex Travelli I've covered India for the past 11 years. Narendra Modi has just won re-election as India's prime minister, though by a far narrower margin than expected. With his third consecutive term, the charismatic strongman has still sealed his position as the country's most significant leader in generations. Despite having led India for a decade, Modi has in some ways kept his country guessing about his vision. On major issues — India's relationships, its economy, its society and its government — it's still unclear what sort of country Modi wants India to be. In today's newsletter, I'll explain four of the big questions. Where will India find friends? India has spent recent years deepening its relationship with the United States. It has gotten closer to American allies, including Japan and Australia, and ordered high-end American weapons systems — the kind that create dependence down the road. And it is unlikely to side with China. In 2020, Chinese troops crossed into territory controlled by India and killed 20 soldiers in a skirmish. Modi has kept Beijing at arm's length since then. But Modi, 73, has signaled that he doesn't want to be a U.S. ally. Some officials in his inner circle still regard the United States warily. American diplomats complain about New Delhi's apparent efforts to erode democratic norms and the rights of minority groups. So India keeps its options open. After Russia invaded Ukraine, the United States tried in vain to persuade India to take a stand against the war. India still processes Russian oil (picking up the slack created by international sanctions). It still buys weapons from Russia. India spent the Cold War trying to position itself as a nonaligned power. Old habits die hard. Workers in a factory in Coimbatore, India. Atul Loke for The New York Times What type of economy? India recently overtook China as the most populous country and the fastest-growing large economy. Still, most of the country remains poor. Some 800 million people need help filling their stomachs. Modi's ideas about how to help them can be contradictory — they're both globally minded and protectionist. One path would be to follow East Asian countries, which escaped poverty by manufacturing goods for export. To that end, Modi unfurled a "Make in India" initiative in 2014, an effort to replace China as the world's factory. But exports have barely risen, even as Modi has thrown new subsidies at them. Some Indian economists say it's better to focus on exporting services, like I.T. and remote professional work. Another Modi vision is for a "self-reliant India," which would reduce the country's exposure to global supply chains. Shielding Indian companies from foreign competition is at odds with preparing them for it. In the face of big economic decisions, Modi sometimes seems equivocal. Like Reagan and Thatcher, he came to power promising to pare down government. In practice, the state wields a heavy hand in most sectors — imposing radical, sometimes half-baked reforms by decree. Protecting minority groups? India's founders crafted a constitution for a diverse and secular republic. Modi has been recasting the country as an explicitly Hindu nation. He converted Jammu and Kashmir, the country's only Muslim-majority state, into a heavily policed federal territory. He built a giant Hindu temple on a disputed site where mobs had torn down a mosque. During the campaign this year, he called Muslims, who make up 14 percent of the population, "infiltrators." India's Muslims say they have been turned into second-class citizens. Modi's third term will be a test: Has the Hindu nationalist project been fulfilled, or is there more he can do to assert one faith's supremacy? The call to put Muslims in their place is the lifeblood of Modi's party, creating winning majorities within a hugely diverse and caste-riven Hindu population. In a third term, Modi could choose new targets, for instance by agitating for more Hindu temples to replace historic mosques. He may be constrained, however, by his new political partners, who are not beholden to his party's Hindu-first projects. Indian Muslims in Jahangirpuri.  Anindito Mukherjee for The New York Times How much authoritarianism? One reason for Modi's enduring popularity is that he's effective. Modi often imposes reforms suddenly, relying on boldness and even the element of surprise to cut through red tape. He streamlined the tax system and even started a semiconductor industry from scratch. He has no patience for obstacles of any kind. One result is that the world's biggest democracy has set aside many democratic norms. The police have thrown leaders of the opposition in jail, swelling the number of political prisoners. The Election Commission has been stacked with pro-Modi appointees. The judiciary hardly ever stands in the way of government priorities. Modi seems to have kept his job but lost his parliamentary majority. Now he'll need to placate coalition partners and consult them on major changes. Maybe that will protect some of the institutions that were built to preserve fair play. The other possibility is that Modi will crack down harder than ever, making full use of the agencies that answer directly to him, to ensure that his party stays ahead of the invigorated competition. Modi has made it this far despite all the complaints about repression. If anything is to hold him back now, it will have to come from within his new governing coalition. For more Modi struggled to stay on top — and three other takeaways from the election. In countries like India and Turkey, where some feared authoritarian leaders would consolidate power, democracy has proved resilient, Mark Landler writes. Global investors have pivoted to India, looking for profits they can't find in China. ADVERTISEMENT THE LATEST NEWS Israel-Hamas War The New York Times visited part of the Sde Teiman base. Avishag Shaar-Yashuv for The New York Times Israel has been holding blindfolded, handcuffed Gazan detainees without legal representation at a military base. See inside. Israel began an offensive in central Gaza, and an Israeli airstrike on a school there killed dozens of people. Israel said it was targeting Hamas; Palestinians said the strike killed displaced civilians. The C.I.A. director met with Qatari and Egyptian officials in an attempt to broker a cease-fire. Qatari officials also met with Hamas leaders, who have yet to formally respond to Israel's latest proposal. (Here are the hurdles to a deal.) Benjamin Netanyahu threatened additional military action against Hezbollah, two days after it launched rockets and drones into northern Israel from Lebanon. Police officers arrested 13 pro-Palestinian protesters who had barricaded themselves in the office of Stanford University's president. D-Day Anniversary George Mullins, an American veteran, at the grave of William Lemaster, who died next to him in northern France in 1944. Laetitia Vancon for The New York Times Today is the 80th anniversary of D-Day, the pivotal World War II battle on beaches in Normandy. Few veterans of the battle are alive. War has returned to Europe. President Biden will visit Normandy and link the fight for Ukraine with the Allied effort on D-Day. 2024 Election After Donald Trump's conviction, The Times contacted participants in past Times/Siena College polls and found a slight shift toward Biden. (Hear some voters explain their decision on the "Run-Up" podcast. ) Trump said he might seek to prosecute political opponents if he won. Threats like that damage the rule of law, legal experts told The Times's Adam Liptak. Byron Donalds, a House Republican and potential Trump running mate, suggested that Jim Crow had an upside for Black Americans because "the Black family was together" and "more Black people voted conservatively." More on Politics An inflatable I.U.D. outside Washington's Union Station this week. Amanda Andrade-Rhoades for The New York Times Senate Republicans blocked a Democratic bill to guarantee access to contraception. Two Republicans, Susan Collins of Maine and Lisa Murkowski of Alaska, voted to advance it. At Hunter Biden's federal trial, his ex-wife and a former girlfriend testified about his drug and alcohol abuse. House Republicans recommended that the Justice Department charge Hunter Biden and James Biden, the president's brother, with lying to Congress. Republicans' claims appear to include misrepresentations of Hunter Biden's testimony. International The Slovak prime minister spoke publicly for the first time since an assassination attempt hospitalized him. A train crash in the Czech Republic killed at least four people. Papua New Guinea will end its search for victims of a landslide that leveled remote villages. It appears to have killed hundreds of people, rather than thousands, as local officials once feared. A gunman opened fire on the U.S. Embassy in Lebanon, injuring a security guard before Lebanese security forces shot and captured him. Congestion Pricing Gov. Kathy Hochul of New York abruptly halted a plan to charge drivers who enter the busiest parts of Manhattan. It had been set to take effect this month, and she cited economic harm for her change of mind. The program, known as congestion pricing, would have been the first of its kind in the U.S., with proceeds funding public transit. Similar programs in London, Singapore and Stockholm have largely succeeded. Other Big Stories In Cape Canaveral, Fla. Joe Raedle/Getty Images The Boeing Starliner spacecraft carried two NASA astronauts into orbit after years of costly delays. Separately, SpaceX is set this morning to launch Starship, the largest rocket built. Leaders of a California city voted to stop scientists from testing a salt-spraying device they say could help cool the planet. The officials cited health risks, despite a report finding none. F.D.A. advisers recommended that Covid vaccine manufacturers update their shots to combat new variants ahead of a fall vaccination campaign. Opinions Isolationism is a delusion. The only way to make America safe is to build its defense now, Senator Mitch McConnell writes. Miami's needle exchange program proves harm reduction can work even in red states, Maia Szalavitz writes. Here's a column by Lydia Polgreen on India's elections. Readers of The Morning: For a limited time, enjoy 7 free days. Discover all of The Times, from expert coverage to games to cooking, sports and more, free for one week, then $1/week for your first six months. Try The Times now. MORNING READS Coney Island. Karsten Moran for The New York Times 36 Hours: There's so much to do in Brooklyn in the summertime. A local writer picked her favorite spots. Wing bearers: In Britain, owls take a starring role in weddings. Social Q's: "Is it disrespectful to my dead father if I speak to his estranged brother?" Health: A report highlights the persistence of long Covid for millions of Americans. Lives Lived: Bertien van Manen was a Dutch photographer who captured intimate images of daily life in China's discos and villages, in post-Soviet Russia and in Kentucky mining country. She died at 89. SPORTS N.B.A.: The Dallas Mavericks and the Boston Celtics face off tonight in Game 1 of the N.B.A. Finals. W.N.B.A.: Chicago Sky players reported being harassed outside their team hotel in Washington, less than a week after the Sky guard Chennedy Carter's hard foul on Caitlin Clark sparked outrage. College football: The schedule for the sport's first 12-team playoff is published. ADVERTISEMENT ARTS AND IDEAS Benjamin Bolger  Benjamin Bolger, 48, has spent his life earning degrees: 14 advanced degrees, as well as an associate's and a bachelor's. He has studied at Brandeis, Brown, Columbia, Dartmouth, Harvard, Oxford, Stanford, Yale and elsewhere, and is now pursuing a master's at Cambridge. In an era of cynicism about higher education, Joseph Bernstein explores what we can learn from him. More on culture Jenna Lyons, a former J. Crew president and "Real Housewives of New York City" star, hosted a stoop sale. This is what she sold. Late night hosts joked about Boeing. THE MORNING RECOMMENDS … Couscous risotto with tomatoes and mozzarella. Kerri Brewer for The New York Times. Use pearl couscous instead of rice to halve your stirring time for this caprese-inspired "risotto." Calm caffeine-related anxiety. Upgrade your sleeper sofa. GAMES Here is today's Spelling Bee. Yesterday's pangram was beekeeping. And here are today's Mini Crossword, Wordle, Sudoku, Connections and Strands. Thanks for spending part of your morning with The Times. See you tomorrow. Sign up here to get this newsletter in your inbox. Reach our team at themorning@nytimes.com. Editor: David Leonhardt Deputy Editor: Adam B. Kushner News Editor: Tom Wright-Piersanti Associate Editor: Lauren Jackson News Staff: Desiree Ibekwe, Sean Kawasaki-Culligan, Brent Lewis, German Lopez, Ian Prasad Philbrick, Ashley Wu News Assistant: Lyna Bentahar Saturday Writer: Melissa Kirsch Need help? Review our newsletter help page or contact us for assistance. You received this email because you signed up for the Morning newsletter from The New York Times, or as part of your New York Times account. To stop receiving The Morning, unsubscribe. To opt out of other promotional emails from The Times, including those regarding The Athletic, manage your email settings. To opt out of updates and offers sent from The Athletic, submit a request. Subscribe to The TimesGet The New York Times app Connect with us on: Change Your EmailPrivacy PolicyContact UsCalifornia Notices The New York Times Company. 620 Eighth Avenue New York, NY 10018